We went with some cute and somewhat gender neutral bedding from Land of Nod (the Crate and Barrel kids store).
Crib --> (ignore the bedding inside the crib, this isn't what we are getting)
Dresser (which will also be used as a changing table!) -->
Bedding Set #1 -->
Bedding Set #2 -->
Hopefully we'll like everything when we receive it in the mail in a few weeks!!